“I need you to find out before I’m gone. Even though I swore I’d carry it to my grave.”
A dozen questions crowded in at once. Was my real father alive somewhere? Had he hidden letters from me? Was there another family, another version of Frank I’d never been allowed to meet?
His hand shook as he pulled a folded scrap of paper from beneath the blanket and pressed it into my palm.
“Go there. Tonight.”
“I’m not leaving you.”
“You have to.” Tears slid into the gray stubble along his jaw. “Please, Rosalie.”
He hadn’t called me Rosalie since I was small.
I bent down close to his face. “Just tell me yourself.”
His eyes drifted shut. “Some truths need a different voice than mine.”
Those were the last words he ever said to me.
The monitor began to chirp, and a nurse hurried in to check his pulse and adjust the oxygen. “He’s still with us,” she said quietly. “But he may not wake again.”
Out in the hallway, I unfolded the paper. An address, written in Frank’s shaking hand, less than twenty minutes from the house he’d raised me in.
I almost threw it away. Whatever was behind that door couldn’t possibly matter more than the man dying in the room behind me.
Then I remembered the look on his face. It hadn’t been fear of dying. It had been fear that I’d never truly understand him.
I got in the car.
For illustrative purposes only
PART TWO — The House With the Star Cutter
I drove through streets gone empty and gray, both hands locked on the wheel, inventing worse and worse possibilities the whole way there. A secret wife. A stranger waiting to tell me Frank had never wanted me at all.
The woman who opened the door had silver hair, pale blue eyes, and one hand pressed over her mouth like she was looking at something impossible.
“Rosalie,” she breathed.
I actually flinched. “Who are you?”
“Caroline.” She kept staring, like she couldn’t quite believe I was real. “Frank called me last month. He could barely get the words out. He said you might come one day.”
“Might?”
“He was hoping he’d finally find the courage to send you.” She stepped back from the door. “I think you’d better come in.”
Every instinct told me to turn around and drive straight back to the hospital. I went inside anyway.
“Tell me what he lied about,” I said.
Caroline didn’t answer right away. She opened a drawer beside the stove and set it in front of me — a small collection of metal cookie cutters. A heart. A flower. A little rabbit. An apple. And one small, battered star.
I stopped breathing. It was identical to the one Frank had used every Sunday of my life.
“Where did you get that?”
“It was Frank’s.”
“No — his is at my house. I have it.”
“He had two, dear,” Caroline said gently.
Beneath the cutters was a photograph. She lifted it out and handed it to me with both hands, like it was something fragile.
A little girl stood beside a kitchen table, grinning down at a plate of star-shaped apple pancakes. She couldn’t have been more than five. Frank stood behind her, younger, thinner, and happier than I had ever once seen him in my life.
“Who is she?”
Caroline’s voice shook. “Her name was Miley.”
The room seemed to tilt around that single word.
“Frank was married before your mother,” she went on. “Miley was his daughter.”
My fingers dug into the edges of the photo. “Where is she now?”
Caroline’s eyes dropped. “She died. She was five.”
The words landed soft, which somehow made them land harder.
“There was an accident, at a lake. It happened fast. Frank blamed himself for years, even though there was nothing anyone could have done.”
I sat down because my legs had stopped agreeing to hold me up.
“Why would he hide that from me?”
“After Miley died, his marriage came apart,” Caroline said. “He stopped talking to almost everyone. Stopped returning my calls, and we’d been close for years. He packed away every photograph, every toy, anything that would remind him he’d once been someone’s father.”
My eyes went back to the small star cutter on the table.
“The pancakes.”
“He made them for her first.”
For illustrative purposes only
PART THREE — What the Table Never Told Me
Caroline sat down across from me, folding her hands like she was steadying herself for what came next.
“Then one morning, not long after he married your mother, you climbed into his lap and fell asleep against him. When you woke up, you asked him if he knew how to make pancakes shaped like stars.”
“I don’t remember that at all.”
“You were four.”
She set the cutter down between us.
“He called me that same afternoon. He was crying so hard I could barely make out the words. He told me he’d made the pancakes. He said he’d said Miley’s name out loud for the first time in years, and it hadn’t destroyed him.”
My hand tightened on the edge of the table.
“He didn’t hand you something that used to belong to his daughter,” Caroline said. “You gave him a way to keep her close without it killing him to remember her.”
The kitchen blurred behind my tears. “Then what was the lie?”
She looked toward the window, gathering herself.
“After your mother died, Frank packed his truck.”
My stomach dropped. “He was going to leave?”
“He drove straight here, that same night. He said your aunt could raise you. He said staying would be selfish of him.”
“Selfish?”
“He was terrified, Rosalie.” Her voice cracked. “He told me — I remember it exactly — ‘Every time she laughs, I hear Miley. Every time she runs toward the street, I stop breathing. I can’t survive burying another daughter.’”
Something in my chest ached in a way I didn’t have a name for.
“He promised me he’d stay. He told me he’d never leave.”
“He made that promise after he sat in this kitchen until sunrise,” Caroline said softly. “He kept telling me he wasn’t strong enough to love another child. That loving you would be the thing that finally broke him.”
“What did you say to him?”
“I told him not to run from loving you out of fear. I told him to stay, because he already did love you — he just hadn’t let himself say it yet.”
A sound came out of me that wasn’t quite a sob.
“He drove home that morning,” she continued. “Unpacked the truck before you were even awake. Thanked your aunt for staying with you through the night. And then he got down on the floor under that kitchen table and promised a four-year-old girl he would never leave her.”
I pressed a hand over my mouth.
That promise had been the floor my whole life stood on. I’d always believed he made it without a second thought — that he stayed simply because I needed him to. I had never once imagined how close he’d come to walking away, or how hard he’d had to fight himself to turn the truck around.
“He almost left me,” I said, the words barely making it out.
“Yes.”
Caroline didn’t try to cushion it. She let it sit there, true and painful, exactly as it was.
“But he came back,” she said quietly.
“Why hide all of this from me?”
See more on the next page